Katriina Tahka
April 10, 2023
Leadership, Workplace Relations

Workplace Investigations: How to Get It Right

By now many people in Australia will know Todd Carney’s name for all the wrong reasons. After his infamous ‘bubbling’ photo, he was sacked from his football team.

But what happened next is an important lesson for all companies and HR teams, as Carney took his football team to court for unfair dismissal – and won.

The incident was the last in a line of controversies for him, and it certainly achieved the most public prominence, with many in media and social media expressing their disgust. The tide of public of opinion was certainly not in Carney’s favour, so the management of his team probably thought they were on sure footing when they sacked him. Surely such public notoriety warranted sacking?

Maybe. What’s definite is that it warranted a due diligence process.

Carney won his case on the basis that management didn’t give him the opportunity to plead his case in front of a tribunal.


Seeing this play out reminded me of conversations I’ve had with people in business who have experienced a lack of due diligence and then suffered the repercussions of it later. I’ve heard too many horror stories of threats being thrown around of unfair treatment during employment that make me shudder.

I think it’s especially prevalent for businesses in regional areas. I grew up in a country town and moved to Sydney back in 1999 and have often seen how principles that apply in the city sometimes don’t make it to the regional areas. Not for lack of will, but simply because there is less access to people who can help.

I was once fired and called an “incompetent son of a b*tch” because I lost my grip on a tray of beers I was serving in a restaurant after a patron bumped passed me. Unfortunately, the tray of six schooner beers fell down the back of a nicely dressed lady. The manager walked straight up to me, dragged me by the back of my shirt, called me a few names, and had me removed from the venue. If I knew then what I know now, I could have had a workplace relations case of unfair dismissal because I didn’t get a chance to plead my case.

Cases like this expose business to risk in terms of litigation as well as reputation damage, and it’s our job as HR professionals to help businesses understand this risk and mitigate against it.

We recently helped one of our SME clients develop HR processes relating to people and performance management. In doing this, our client felt more confident in dealing with performance issues, addressing tricky situations and having difficult conversations. They didn’t have the budget to bring on a permanent HR headcount, so are using our Virtual HR team to access one of our talented team members when they need it.

A Human Agency’s brand is based on everyone deserving great HR. That’s why we’re keen to help more SME clients, especially in regional areas, access the expertise they need (without the overheads!). Our team has expertise in dealing with performance matters head on so they don’t turn ugly.

Have you seen a lack of due process in your workplace? How have you addressed it?

Let's Go


Confidential consultation

We offer an initial, confidential appointment tailored to address your questions and guide you in the right direction, whether you're embarking on a new HR journey or seeking expert advice and guidance on complex workplace issues.

This allows us to learn about your business goals and objectives; and for you to get to know our team and how we can support you to achieve those goals.

Our sessions are designed to:

  • understand your specific questions, covering your current situation, potential challenges in culture, behaviour, performance, diversity or inclusion, and any other concerns you may have.
  • Collaboratively assess your current landscape and outline actionable steps towards meaningful change, providing assurance and support along the way.
  • Most importantly establish a foundation for working together. We want you to feel confident that we are the right HR partner for you, because this is your business’ future you are about to invest in, so we need to get it right. 

We look forward to meeting you.


A-HA connects business and people in order to realise genuine value and worth. We have pioneered a new type of agency which revolutionises the human resource industry through our people, products and insight.


Sydney Office Suite 1, 281 Pacific Hwy North Sydney, 20600491 235 263Email Us

ABN: 21 600 655 365

© A Human Agency | A-HA! and www.a-ha.com.au, Copyright 2015-2024

Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to A Human Agency and www.a-ha.com.au with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.

The team at A Human Agency would like to acknowledge and pay respects to the traditional custodians of the land where our office is based, the Cammeraygal and Wallumedegal peoples of the Eora nation. We pay our respects to Elders past, present and emerging and celebrate the diversity of Aboriginal people and their ongoing cultures and connections to the lands and waters of NSW.